Newoldstamp alternative: free and actually usable
Newoldstamp built a genuinely strong signature-marketing product — mature banner campaigns, click analytics, and A/B testing. But its free tier lets you design a signature you can't actually install: per Newoldstamp's own trial messaging, you can't start using a signature until you upgrade. EmailSignatured takes the opposite approach: the free signature you build is the real, usable one.
| Feature | EmailSignatured | Newoldstamp |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free forever and fully usable — copy, download, and install it today. | The free standalone generator lets you design a signature, but you can't install or actually use it until you pick a paid plan; the same lock applies during the 7-day trial. |
| Editor access | Anonymous editor — build and preview with no signup. | A design-only anonymous generator exists, but it funnels into signup for the app before you can use what you built. |
| Templates | 9 templates, all included and installable free. | 20+ base templates, some supporting animated GIFs and legal disclaimers. |
| Pricing model | Free for individuals; one clear, published price when team tiers launch. | Pricing is inconsistent across Newoldstamp's own site and third-party trackers: a live slider (~$1.80/signature/mo, 5-signature minimum, roughly $9–11/mo floor) versus separately reported named tiers (~$8 and ~$11/mo) that don't fully reconcile (as of August 2026). |
| Campaign analytics | Coming as an addon; not part of v1. | Mature: banner impression and click/CTA tracking in real time, UTM parameters flowing into Google Analytics, and a documented A/B testing workflow — this is genuinely their strongest feature. |
| Team rollout | Team rollout ships today: personal /join links + CSV import with locked branding. | Automated sync for Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, and Exchange from a central dashboard, with per-employee install-status tracking. |
| White-label / agency | Our flagship: workspace branding ships today, self-serve; agency sub-workspaces coming. | Markets a "White Label Signature Generator" for agencies, but pricing, self-serve setup, and technical depth aren't publicly documented — it reads as a sales-assisted, contact-us offering. |
| Install methods | Rich clipboard copy, HTML source copy, HTML file download, plus per-client guides. | Automated sync for supported platforms, plus manual copy-paste with illustrated guides for Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail, Thunderbird, and more. |
When Newoldstamp is the better pick
If banner performance data matters to you today — impressions, click-throughs, A/B-tested variants feeding into Google Analytics — Newoldstamp's campaign analytics are mature and genuinely ahead of what we offer right now; ours is still on the roadmap. Their automated Workspace/365/Exchange sync also works today for teams that need it immediately.
Newoldstamp's own reviewers describe pricing as inconsistent and cancellation as a hard cutoff with no grace period. EmailSignatured avoids the design-then-paywall pattern entirely: what you build for free is what you get to actually use, with one clear price list and self-serve cancellation once paid tiers exist.