Newoldstamp alternative: free and actually usable
Newoldstamp built a genuinely strong signature-marketing product — mature banner campaigns, click analytics, and A/B testing. But its free tier lets you design a signature you can't actually install: per Newoldstamp's own trial messaging, you can't start using a signature until you upgrade. EmailSignatured takes the opposite approach: the free signature you build is the real, usable one.
Swipe the table sideways to see both columns.
| Feature | EmailSignatured | Newoldstamp |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free forever and fully usable — copy, download, and install it today. | The free standalone generator lets you design a signature, but you can't install or actually use it until you pick a paid plan; the same lock applies during the 7-day trial. |
| Editor access | Anonymous editor — build and preview with no signup. | A design-only anonymous generator exists, but it funnels into signup for the app before you can use what you built. |
| Templates | 9 templates, all included and installable free. | 20+ base templates, some supporting animated GIFs and legal disclaimers. |
| Pricing model | Free for individuals; one clear, published price for teams — $9/mo flat with everything included, $25/mo unlimited. | Pricing is inconsistent across Newoldstamp's own site and third-party trackers: a live slider (~$1.80/signature/mo, 5-signature minimum, roughly $9–11/mo floor) versus separately reported named tiers (~$8 and ~$11/mo) that don't fully reconcile (as of August 2026). |
| Campaign analytics | Ships today, included in both business plans: swap the banner centrally and every signature installed while a campaign was running follows it, with nobody re-installing. Click counts only — no impressions, no UTM handoff into Google Analytics, no A/B testing. Theirs is deeper. | Mature: banner impression and click/CTA tracking in real time, UTM parameters flowing into Google Analytics, and a documented A/B testing workflow — this is genuinely their strongest feature. |
| Team rollout | Team rollout ships today: personal /join links + CSV import with locked branding. | Automated sync for Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, and Exchange from a central dashboard, with per-employee install-status tracking. |
| White-label / agency | Our flagship: workspace branding ships today, self-serve; agency sub-workspaces coming. | Markets a "White Label Signature Generator" for agencies, but pricing, self-serve setup, and technical depth aren't publicly documented — it reads as a sales-assisted, contact-us offering. |
| Install methods | Rich clipboard copy, HTML source copy, HTML file download, plus per-client guides. | Automated sync for supported platforms, plus manual copy-paste with illustrated guides for Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail, Thunderbird, and more. |
When Newoldstamp is the better pick
If banner performance data matters to you today — impressions, click-throughs, A/B-tested variants feeding into Google Analytics — Newoldstamp's campaign analytics are mature and genuinely ahead of what we offer right now; ours is still on the roadmap. Their automated Workspace/365/Exchange sync also works today for teams that need it immediately.
Newoldstamp's published prices don't reconcile with what third-party trackers report, and its own cancellation policy is a hard cutoff — signatures stop working the day the subscription expires, with no stated grace period. EmailSignatured avoids the design-then-paywall pattern entirely: what you build for free is what you get to actually use, with one clear price list and self-serve cancellation.
Newoldstamp details were checked in August 2026 from their own public pricing, help and product pages, plus published customer reviews where the row says so. Prices and plan limits change — if you spot something out of date here, tell us at hello@emailsignatured.com and we'll correct it.